Father Gives Son Ride On Shoulders As Family Leave House

How to get the right home insurance according to an expert

By: Alyshia McCabe
Published Date:
Modified Date: Aug. 17, 2023

2 Minute Read

Buying a home is the single largest purchase most Canadians make. So, it’s important to understand the role of home insurance in protecting your investment. 

To help you make an informed choice about home insurance, we spoke with Elliott Silverstein, Director of Government Relations (Insurance) at CAA. He answered Members’ top questions, including how to pick the right home insurance and common mistakes to avoid. 

What should homeowners know about home insurance?

Silverstein says home insurance is ultimately about peace of mind. Your home is often the largest investment you’ll make, so you want to ensure both your house and everything inside it can be repaired or replaced if something happens.

While home insurance isn’t legally required, Silverstein points out that it is mandatory if you have a mortgage. He stresses the importance of ensuring your home is adequately insured by accurately assessing the value of the house and its contents. High-value items should be specifically listed on your policy using a rider. He also emphasizes having liability coverage and coverage for additional living expenses if your home becomes uninhabitable.

What types of coverage are available?

couple looking at papers

Silverstein explains that most insurers offer three main types of coverage. Actual cash value covers property and belongings at their depreciated value, meaning payouts are reduced to account for wear and tear, making it the least expensive option. 
 
Replacement cost value coverage pays to replace your home and personal belongings at current market value using the same or similar materials, minus your deductible. Guaranteed or extended replacement cost coverage protects against inflation, which Silverstein says is especially important when building materials increase in cost, since standard replacement coverage may not be enough on its own.

How do you determine how much coverage you need?

Silverstein says choosing the right coverage starts with understanding the replacement cost of your home, the total value of your belongings, and the value of your overall assets, including vehicles and other high-value items. 
 
Estimates can be obtained from your insurer, through a third-party replacement cost calculator, or by hiring an assessor, and he suggests getting multiple opinions to ensure accuracy. When calculating the value of personal belongings, Silverstein recommends keeping a photo record and documenting items in a spreadsheet or app, along with receipts or current values. He notes that expensive items such as jewelry, art, and décor should be professionally assessed, and that liability coverage should be sufficient to protect all assets. He also advises keeping this information stored securely online or in a safe place so it can be easily accessed and updated.

What home insurance mistakes should be avoided?

Silverstein cautions against choosing a policy based solely on price. While cheaper coverage may fit your budget in the short term, it might not provide sufficient protection when you need it most.

Another key mistake, he says, is failing to update coverage annually. Replacement costs change over time, and values from a year ago may no longer be accurate. Silverstein highlights that CAA offers free policy reviews to help Members ensure their coverage reflects current realities and rising costs.

He also points out that Members may miss out on savings if they don’t contact CAA first. CAA Members can save on home insurance and even more by bundling it with auto insurance. Call 1-888-545-7254 or go online to get a quote

Auto and Property Insurance is underwritten by CAA Insurance Company. Certain conditions, limitations and underwriting guidelines apply.

*To qualify for the discount, you must be a current CAA Member in good standing (CAA Membership dues paid in full by membership expiry date).

® CAA trademarks are owned by, and use is authorized by, the Canadian Automobile Association.