E-bike and e-scooter use outpaces road safety laws to govern them, CAA study finds
As usage of electric bicycles and scooters rises across Canada, a new study released by the Canadian Automobile Association (CAA) has found gaps in safety regulations, data collection, and public awareness that pose a potential safety risk to Canadians.
The study, commissioned by CAA and conducted by the Traffic Injury Research Foundation (TIRF), surveyed government regulation of e-bikes and e-scooters. It presents findings of Canadian and international research into the road safety risks associated with the use of these devices.
“E-bikes and e-scooters offer Canadians a convenient, eco-friendly, and affordable option to get around,” says Julie Beun, managing director of communications and public relations at CAA North & East Ontario. “But since they began appearing on our roads and bike lanes, it’s apparent that their rapid adoption is outpacing the rules meant to keep vulnerable road users safe.”
The report reveals six key findings:
-
Regulatory gaps – Many jurisdictions have yet to establish road safety rules for e-bikes and e-scooters, such as speed limits or permitted riding areas.
-
Shared-use fleets are ahead on safety– Public e-bike and e-scooter share programs often abide by stricter regulations and safety measures than personal devices, including geofencing, speed limits and higher minimum rider age.
-
Need for continued public education – Safety information and guidance is limited. As a leader in road safety advocacy, CAA provides information on e-bikes and e-scooters on our website and promotes safety tips to road users.
-
Limited safety research – Understanding of the potential risks associated with these devices remains incomplete.
-
Data gaps – Official collision data is inconsistent and often lacks key details, including recording whether an e-bike or e-scooter was involved.
-
Battery and modification risks – Uncertified imports of lithium-ion batteries and speed alterations can increase risks of fire and injury hazards for personally-owned devices. High operating standards mitigate these potential risks for shared fleets.
These issues underscore the report’s recommendation that jurisdictions review existing policies and make sure they have basic road safety rules for e-bikes and e-scooters —such as speed limits and sidewalk restrictions.
City of Ottawa bylaws permit shared and personal e-scooters on multi-use pathways, cycling facilities, bike lanes and on roads with speed limits lower than 50 kilometres an hour. They are not permitted on sidewalks.
“It’s critical that municipalities and stakeholders consult when developing riding regulations. Key considerations for designating riding areas should include existing infrastructure,” says Robyn Robertson, TIRF President & CEO. “Typical speeds of micromobility devices differ from other modes of transport, meaning designating appropriate riding areas is necessary to mitigate conflicts between these modes.”
Key takeaways:
-
International studies show that sidewalk use is a leading cause of e-scooter injuries, which likely explains why many jurisdictions in this study have banned e-bikes and e-scooters from sidewalks.
-
Available data on the safety risks of these relatively new micromobility devices is sparse. However, based on the research available, the study found the most common injuries can be more severe than for non-electric bicycles because they often happen at higher speeds.
-
Unless a motor vehicle is part of the collision, there is very little likelihood an incident involving an e-scooter or e-bike will even be recorded.
-
The study highlights found that in many municipalities, rental fleets are subject to stricter rules than personal devices, particularly regarding curfews and designated parking.
“CAA is urging jurisdictions to share information and work together to keep pace with this fast-evolving field. The often-stricter rules and safety measures for shared fleets set good safety standards, and there is an opportunity to apply these more consistently across personal devices to help create clarity,” says Ian Jack, vice-president, public affairs, CAA National.
“We need more and better data collection on collisions involving e-bikes and e-scooters. Without it, we can’t identify trends that increase potential risk to riders—and without those insights, we miss the opportunity to shape smarter laws that help prevent collisions and injuries,” he says.
CAA’s five tips for safe riding on e-bikes and e-scooters:
-
Before you ride, check your brakes, tires, and lights.
-
Protect yourself by always wearing a helmet and dress to be visible.
-
Always ride sober.
-
While you ride, start slow, stay alert, and ride solo in a single file.
-
Be aware of any road rules and be mindful of pedestrians, and for everyone’s safety, please stay off the sidewalks.
About CAA
CAA is a federation of eight Clubs providing over 7 million Members with exceptional emergency roadside service, complete automotive and travel services, Member savings and comprehensive insurance services. As one of Canada’s most trusted brands, CAA also advocates on issues of concern to its Members and all Canadians, including road safety, the environment, mobility, infrastructure, and consumer protection.
About TIRF Canada
The vision of the Traffic Injury Research Foundation (TIRF) is to ensure people using roads make it home safely every day by eliminating road deaths, serious injuries and their social costs. TIRF’s mission is to be the knowledge source for safe road users and a world leader in research, program and policy development, evaluation, and knowledge transfer. TIRF is a registered charity and depends on grants, awards, and donations to provide services for the public. Visit www.tirf.ca or find all TIRF websites and social media at linktr.ee/tirfcanada.